9 fiery Carolina reaper hot sauces (+ a simple recipe!)


Known for their blistering heat, Carolina Reapers reign supreme on the Scoville scale, boasting a staggering range of 1,400,000 to 2,200,000 Scoville Heat Units (SHU). It’s no wonder they have become a sought-after choice for hot sauce enthusiasts who crave an intense flavor experience.

Brace yourself for an exploration of some of the hottest commercially available Carolina Reaper hot sauces, each promising a fiery adventure for your taste buds. 

Or, if you’re looking to take control of the heat level and infuse your hot sauce with personalized flavors, we’ve got you covered with a simple homemade recipe. 

How hot is Carolina Reaper hot sauce?

Carolina Reaper hot sauces come in a range of heat levels, with each sauce offering its own unique intensity. Using ingredients like vinegar, garlic, onions, and seasonings helps to temper the spiciness of the Carolina Reaper peppers. As a result, the Scoville Heat Units (SHU) of the hot sauce will be lower than that of the raw peppers unless other, hotter peppers or capsaicin extract are included.

However, it’s essential to note that Carolina Reaper hot sauce is still incredibly fiery and not recommended for those not accustomed to spicy food. Its intense heat can be overwhelming for individuals who aren’t confident in handling extreme spiciness. So, if you’re up for a fiery adventure, Carolina Reaper hot sauce will surely provide a thrilling experience for your taste buds.

9 Carolina Reaper hot sauces you need to try immediately

Note: This article contains affiliate links, which means that if you click and purchase, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting our content!

Kickin’ Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce

styled graphic of hot sauce bottle with text "embrace the heat carolina reaper hot sauce"

Ingredients: Water, Carolina Reaper Pepper, Vinegar, Carrots, Salt, Fresh Garlic, Xanthan Gum, and Spices.

Kickin’ Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce is not for the faint of heart. This sauce brings the heat with a powerful intensity that will make your taste buds scream. Unlike some hot sauces that rely on capsaicin extract, Kickin’ Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce derives its fiery kick solely from chili peppers, delivering an authentic and intense heat experience.

This hot sauce balances extreme heat and robust flavor with a tangy touch of vinegar. While it may not claim the title of the hottest hot sauce in the world, Kickin’ Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce remains a formidable contender, offering a potent combination of intense spiciness and taste.

Exercise caution when trying this hot sauce, as its heat level surpasses most other varieties. Start with just a few drops to gradually introduce your palate to its fiery nature. Prepare for an explosive heat experience with Kickin’ Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce, where intense flavor and scorching heat converge.

Check the price of this hot sauce.

Elijah’s Xtreme Regret Reserve Hotter Hot Sauce

bottle and box of eliha's xtreme hot sauce

Ingredients: Carolina reaper, scorpion, and habanero peppers, water, salt, sugar, cane sugar, garlic, tomato paste, apple cider vinegar, onion, lime, passion fruit, citric and acetic acids, ascorbic acid, xanthan gum

Prepare yourself for a scorching experience with Elijah’s Xtreme Regret Reserve Hotter Hot Sauce. Known for their exceptionally spicy creations, Elijah’s has crafted a sauce that is not to be taken lightly. This sauce combines three super-hot peppers: Carolina Reaper, Scorpion, and Habanero, resulting in an ultra-spicy concoction that will leave a lasting impression.

With an estimated Scoville Heat Unit (SHU) rating of 999,999 based on the relative volume of peppers used, Elijah’s Xtreme Regret Reserve Hotter Hot Sauce is not for the faint-hearted. However, it’s not just about the heat. This sauce showcases a balance between intense spiciness and fruity flavors. Adding lime and passion fruit enhances the natural fruitiness of the peppers, resulting in a taste-forward experience.

Thicker and sweeter than some other hot sauces, Elijah’s Xtreme Regret Reserve Hotter Hot Sauce offers a satisfying texture and a touch of sweetness that complements its fiery nature. Prepare yourself for a flavor journey where the tantalizing taste takes the spotlight before the heat makes its presence known. Proceed with caution as you savor Elijah’s Xtreme Regret Reserve Hotter Hot Sauce, a hot sauce that will leave a lasting impression.

Check the price of this hot sauce.

Dave’s Gourmet Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce

a bottle of dave's carolina reaper hot sauce

Ingredients: Carolina reaper peppers, water, salt, cane vinegar, hot pepper extract, acetic acid, garlic, xanthan gum 

Dave’s Gourmet stands out as a trusted brand regarding reliability and consistency. Their Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce is a testament to their commitment to delivering heat-packed flavor experiences. Unlike some other brands, this sauce takes a heat-forward approach, focusing squarely on the spiciness.

Dave’s Gourmet Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce combines the intensity of Carolina Reapers with the added kick of hot pepper extract. This bold combination ensures extra heat that will ignite your taste buds. However, it’s important to exercise caution when handling this sauce. The wide mouth of the bottle can make it challenging to control the amount you pour, and even a tiny drop is often all most people can handle.

While Dave’s Gourmet Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce may have fewer supporting ingredients than other brands, its straightforward approach to heat sets it apart. Get ready to experience a tongue-tingling sensation as you unleash the fiery power of this hot sauce.

Check the price of this hot sauce.

Bravado Black Garlic And Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce (Hot Ones Season 6)

a bottle of bravado black garlic carolina reaper hot sauce

Ingredients: Vinegar, Red Serrano, Carolina Reaper, Roasted Garlic, Maple Syrup, Black Garlic, Black Pepper, Sea Salt

Featured on Hot Ones Season 6, Bravado Black Garlic and Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce is a unique combination of sweet, savory, and flavor-forward elements. 

While it packs a considerable amount of heat, it is comparatively less spicy than many other Carolina Reaper hot sauces, thanks to the higher proportion of red serrano peppers in the recipe. The addition of maple syrup provides a subtle sweetness, while the star ingredients, garlic, and black garlic, take the spotlight with their robust flavors. Get ready to savor the perfect balance of heat and flavor in Bravado Black Garlic and Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce.

Check the price of this hot sauce.

Hellfire Hot Sauce Kranked (Hot Ones Season 16)

a bottle of hellfire kranked hot sauce surrounded by black garlic

Ingredients: Reaper pepper mash (reapers and vinegar), apple cider vinegar, red wine vinegar, black garlic, garlic, sea salt, brown sugar (cane sugar and molasses), chili powder, cumin, onions, black pepper, curry powder (spices, turmeric, salt, contains mustard), oregano, paprika, ginger, cloves, turmeric, lemon juice from concentrate, lime juice from concentrate

Hellfire Hot Sauce Kranked, another star from Hot Ones, will captivate your taste buds with its bold flavor profile. Just like the Bravado hot sauce, Kranked showcases the rich essence of black garlic, contributing to its distinctive taste.

In addition to the garlic and black garlic, this sauce incorporates a medley of warm spices that further elevate its flavor complexity. The exceptional combination of ingredients has earned Kranked the prestigious first place at the NYC Hot Sauce Expo, solidifying its status as a top-notch hot sauce.

While Kranked promises a remarkable taste experience, it’s important to note that, true to its Carolina Reaper base, it delivers an intense spiciness. Hellfire rates this sauce a formidable 9/10 in terms of heat, ensuring a fiery encounter that will test the limits of your heat tolerance.

Check the price of this hot sauce.

Mad Dog 357 Gold Edition

a bottle of mad dog 357

Ingredients: Reaper, Scorpion & Ghost peppers, red wine vinegar, white distilled vinegar, fresh chopped onions & garlic, natural sugar, fresh lime juice, Chile extract & xanthan gum.

Get ready to experience scorching heat with Mad Dog 357 Gold Edition hot sauce. This blend of Carolina reapers, scorpion, and Ghost peppers creates an intensely spicy sensation that reportedly surpasses 1 million Scoville Heat Units (SHU). This hot sauce also includes a chili extract to take the heat up a notch.

Mad Dog 357 Gold Edition is not for the faint of heart. It prioritizes heat over flavor, making it the perfect choice for those seeking an extremely spicy encounter. If you’re looking for an intense, heat-forward hot sauce, Mad Dog 357 Gold Edition will satisfy your craving.

Check the price of this hot sauce.

Secret Aardvark Reaper Hot Sauce

a bottle of secret aardvark reaper

Ingredients: Tomatoes (tomatoes, roasted tomatoes, tomato juice), carrot, white wine vinegar, smoked reaper pepper mash, yellow onions, cane sugar, smoked sea salt, garlic, spices, yellow mustard (distilled vinegar, mustard seed, salt, turmeric, spices)

Tomatoes and carrots take the lead in Secret Aardvark Reaper Hot Sauce, providing a robust and savory foundation. The inclusion of a smoked reaper pepper mash adds depth and complexity to the flavor profile, enhancing the overall taste experience. Smoked sea salt further contributes to the savory notes, creating a well-rounded sensation in your taste buds.

While Secret Aardvark Reaper Hot Sauce carries some heat, it is milder than some other sauces on this list. This is due to the relative volume of reaper peppers being lower. However, don’t let that deter you, as this sauce still offers a satisfying level of spiciness.

Check the price of this hot sauce.

Fat Cat “Hiss-y Fit” Carolina Reaper Hot Sauce

a bottle of fat cat hissy fit hot sauce

Ingredients: Vinegar, reaper pepper mash (reaper peppers, vinegar), jalapeno pepper mash (jalapeno peppers, salt), roasted red peppers (roasted peppers, water, salt, citric acid), water, cane sugar, garlic, paprika, xanthan gum

Fat Cat takes pride in creating sauces that balance heat and flavor, and “Hiss-y Fit” is no exception. Alongside the peppers, vinegar, and garlic are skillfully blended to enhance the overall richness and depth of the sauce.

This sauce combines the intense heat of Carolina Reapers, the moderate spiciness of jalapeños, and the smoky sweetness of roasted red peppers. It’s a flavor-packed hot sauce that will leave a lasting impression.

Check the price of this hot sauce.

Hellfire Blueberry Hell Hot Sauce

hellfire blueberry hot sauce surrounded by fruit

Ingredients: Blueberries, blackberries, Jolokia peppers, red jalapeno peppers, red serrano peppers, grape juice, sugar, Carolina reaper pepper, raspberries, pears, red wine vinegar, honey, garlic, papaya, orange habanero peppers, pineapple, beets, blueberry puree, sea salt, lemon juice.

Prepare for a unique and intriguing hot sauce experience with Hellfire Blueberry Hell. This sauce stands out from the rest, offering a captivating blend of heat and fruity flavors.

While still providing a satisfying level of spiciness, Hellfire Blueberry Hell is relatively milder than other sauces on the list. It showcases a medley of fruits, including blueberries, blackberries, raspberries, papaya, and pineapple, contributing to its distinct taste profile.

In addition to the variety of fruits, this sauce features a diverse mix of peppers. Alongside Carolina Reapers, you’ll find ghost peppers, red jalapeños, red serranos, and orange habaneros, ensuring a dynamic and complex heat experience. Hellfire rates this sauce a 5/10 on the heat scale, balancing heat and flavor.

The versatility of Hellfire Blueberry Hell makes it a perfect addition to both sweet and savory dishes.

Check the price of this hot sauce.

Easy Carolina Reaper hot sauce recipe you can make at home

If you didn’t find exactly what you’re looking for, why not create your own Carolina Reaper hot sauce at home? With a handful of ingredients and some time, you can whip up a custom hot sauce that caters to your exact taste.

Feel free to adjust the number of peppers in this recipe to suit your preferred heat level, and play with the spices and seasonings so that it is just to your taste!

glass bottle of hot sauce on wooden background

Easy Carolina Reaper hot sauce

This homemade Carolina Reaper hot sauce recipe delivers a fiery and flavorful blend of roasted Carolina Reaper peppers, garlic, vinegar, lime juice, honey, and spices. Perfect for heat seekers and hot sauce enthusiasts, this homemade creation allows you to customize the intensity and flavor of your sauce, providing a unique and personalized taste experience that will add a spicy kick to your favorite dishes.


  • 8-10 Carolina Reaper peppers
  • 1 head garlic
  • 1 cup white vinegar
  • 2 tbsp lime juice
  • 2 tbsp honey
  • 1 tbsp olive oil
  • 1 tsp salt
  • 1 tsp cumin


  • Preheat your oven to 400°F (200°C).
  • Cut the top off the head of garlic to expose the cloves. Place the garlic on aluminum foil and drizzle it with olive oil. Wrap the garlic in the foil to create a packet.
  • Place the Carolina Reaper peppers and the garlic packet on a baking sheet and roast them in the oven for about 20 minutes, or until the peppers are slightly charred and the garlic cloves are soft and golden.
  • Allow the peppers and garlic to cool. Once cool, remove the stems from the Carolina Reaper peppers.
  • In a blender or food processor, combine the roasted Carolina Reaper peppers, roasted garlic cloves (squeezed out from the skins), white vinegar, lime juice, honey, salt, and cumin. Blend until you achieve a smooth and well-combined consistency.
  • Taste the hot sauce and adjust the seasoning according to your preference. 
  • Transfer the hot sauce to a sterilized glass bottle or jar with a tight-fitting lid.
  • Allow the hot sauce to sit for a day or two to allow the flavors to meld together.


Be EXTREMELY cautious when handling Carolina Reaper peppers. You may want to wear gloves when you handle them.
Make sure the roasted peppers cool completely before blending them, and be careful not to inhale the fumes when you remove the lid of your food processor.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating